The initial watch list for the 2026 Matt Wilhelm Award, which recognizes the best high school football player in the region, has been unveiled. Named after former Elyria Catholic Panthers and Ohio State Buckeyes star Matt Wilhelm, this award reflects excellence on the field, honoring players who showcase outstanding talent and leadership. Wilhelm, a champion of both college football and the NFL, is a fitting namesake for an accolade that celebrates the next generation of athletes.
This watch list serves as a preliminary snapshot of players who have the potential to contend for the award throughout the season. Notably, the list will be updated weekly to reflect players’ performances and emerging talents.
Key Players to Watch in 2026
Among the standout candidates is Carter Atwater, a sophomore quarterback from Rocky River. After stepping in for an injured teammate, Atwater demonstrated his skills in five games, completing 20 of 26 passes for a remarkable 548 yards, along with nine touchdowns and a single interception. His leadership will be crucial as the season unfolds.
Another notable player is LaMarcus Clark, a junior running back from Fairview. Clark is set to take over as the primary rusher following the graduation of Burke Lowry, a previous finalist for the award. With the potential shift toward a run-first offense, Clark’s performance will be pivotal for the Warriors as they strive for success.
In the passing game, Patrick Cleary, a junior quarterback from Bay, has made significant strides under the guidance of his new coach, Nick Bigrigg. Cleary achieved an impressive 1,790 passing yards and 20 touchdowns last season, positioning him as a key player in the Rockets’ offense, especially with Brody Beggs returning as a wide receiver.
Wide receiver Fin Jerdonek from Avon also merits attention. Following a successful playoff run, he caught 40 passes for 613 yards and seven touchdown receptions, earning him recognition as an honorable mention in the Division II Northeast Lakes All-District team. His ability to make big plays will be crucial for Avon’s offensive strategy.
On the defensive side, Xavier Hendon, a sophomore running back from Columbia, rushed for 1,211 yards and scored 12 touchdowns last season. His contributions were vital in leading Columbia to a successful 9-2 record and a Lorain County League championship. With three offensive linemen returning, Hendon is set for another strong season.
Also returning is Tristin Hughes, a junior athlete from Rocky River, who previously finished as a finalist for the Matt Wilhelm Award. Hughes was named the CWC Player of the Year after amassing over 1,000 receiving yards and a remarkable 27 touchdowns. His commitment to Syracuse University adds to his profile as a player to watch.
Other notable mentions include Rowan Kennedy, a sophomore wide receiver from Rocky River, who also reached the 1,000 receiving yards mark, and Wyatt McKee, a junior running back and linebacker from Keystone, who narrowly missed a 1,000-yard season with 15 touchdowns.
Looking Ahead to the Season
As the season progresses, players like Dawson TenBrink, a sophomore quarterback from Avon Lake, and Amir Silmi, a sophomore running back from North Olmsted, will also be under scrutiny. TenBrink threw for 1,666 yards but will need to improve his efficiency after throwing 13 interceptions. Meanwhile, Silmi’s impressive performance last season, with 1,097 rushing yards and 12 touchdowns, positions him as a strong contender among returning rushers.
The competition for the Matt Wilhelm Award is expected to be fierce, with players demonstrating remarkable skills and potential. As the season unfolds, fans and coaches alike will be eager to see who rises to the occasion and secures a spot as a finalist for this prestigious award. The early favorite, Tristin Hughes, will undoubtedly be a player to watch as the season progresses.
