PITTSBURGH — The future of Andrew McCutchen with the Pittsburgh Pirates remains uncertain as the team prepares for the 2026 season. Unlike the past three offseasons, during which McCutchen signed a one-year deal worth $5 million with the Pirates, he is currently a free agent. This change reflects the Pirates’ ambitions to end a ten-year playoff drought, having made several significant roster additions to bolster their competitive edge.
At the annual PiratesFest held on January 24, 2026, at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center, fans expressed their hopes for McCutchen’s return. Traditionally a fan favorite, McCutchen’s absence from the event raised questions about his future. Pirates General Manager Ben Cherington addressed these inquiries during the Q&A session, emphasizing the importance of McCutchen’s legacy while also outlining the team’s focus on building a competitive roster for the upcoming season.
Cherington stated, “I think all of us are really excited. I know I am. We have a really good opportunity this year to be ultra-competitive.” He highlighted the improvements made to the team, particularly the pitching rotation, which he believes positions the Pirates to succeed in close games that have eluded them in previous seasons.
Understanding McCutchen’s place in the franchise’s history, Cherington remarked, “Andrew has meant a ton to the team. He’s had an incredible run in two different times with the Pirates. Certainly, his legacy as a Pirate is secure.” While Cherington expressed a desire to maintain a strong relationship with McCutchen, he acknowledged the necessity of prioritizing the team’s overall success.
The Pirates have made notable signings this offseason, including Ryan O’Hearn and Brandon Lowe, both of whom are expected to enhance the team’s offensive capabilities. McCutchen, who has primarily served as the designated hitter in his recent seasons, now faces increased competition for that role from players like Spencer Horwitz, Oneil Cruz, and Bryan Reynolds.
Despite his age of 39, McCutchen has demonstrated his value at the plate, posting a batting line of .242/.345/.391 with an OPS of .736 during his second tenure in Pittsburgh. His experience has made him a critical asset, particularly as the only player on the roster with postseason experience in the city.
As the offseason progresses, it remains to be seen how the Pirates will address McCutchen’s potential role on the team. Cherington acknowledged the need for a right-handed bat, indicating that the organization will continue to communicate with McCutchen directly as decisions are made. “So much respect for Andrew. That relationship is really important to us, and we’ll continue to communicate with him,” he said.
The Pirates are keen on securing a strong roster ahead of the 2026 season, with the ultimate goal of returning to the playoffs. As fans await news on McCutchen’s future, the organization is laser-focused on building a competitive team that can deliver wins at PNC Park. For the latest updates on this developing story, fans can visit Pirates OnSI.
