The announcement of the 2026 Pro Bowl rosters on February 3 has sparked discussion among fans and analysts alike, highlighting several notable omissions from both the AFC and NFC teams. While some players may still secure a spot as replacements due to injuries or Super Bowl commitments, the initial selections have left many questioning the criteria used for inclusion.
NFL analysts Ben Solak and Seth Walder have identified several standout players who were overlooked this year. Their analysis divides these snubs into two categories: those who unequivocally should be included and those who have strong cases for consideration.
Players Who Absolutely Should Be Included
One glaring omission is Jordan Love, quarterback for the Green Bay Packers. Love’s performance has been impressive, holding a 72.8 QBR, ranking third in the NFL, significantly outshining Sam Darnold of the Seattle Seahawks, who has a 60.8 QBR. Despite fewer wins, Love’s lower turnover rate—eight compared to Darnold’s 18—highlights his efficiency.
Another notable snub is Chris Olave, wide receiver for the New Orleans Saints. Olave ranks in the top ten for targets, receptions, receiving yards, and touchdowns, even while navigating a midseason quarterback change. In contrast, Amon-Ra St. Brown of the Detroit Lions has had a more average season, making Olave’s exclusion particularly puzzling.
Defensive tackle Kobie Turner of the Los Angeles Rams also deserves recognition. Leading NFC interior defenders with 34 total pass rush wins and recording 7.0 sacks, Turner has outperformed Jalen Carter of the Philadelphia Eagles, who has played fewer games and posted lower statistics.
Linebacker Jordyn Brooks from the Miami Dolphins has been heralded as the best linebacker this season, excelling in tackles and coverage. His performance has outmatched that of Roquan Smith of the Baltimore Ravens, further solidifying Brooks’ case for inclusion.
Other players who could argue for their positions include Ernest Jones IV of the Seattle Seahawks and Lane Johnson, who is considered the best tackle in football. Johnson’s exclusion, despite his talent, raises eyebrows, especially since he has played significantly more games than some selected players.
Players Who Probably Could Be Included
In the category of strong candidates, Ronnie Stanley of the Baltimore Ravens stands out. Although Joe Alt of the Los Angeles Chargers has made the roster with only six games played, Stanley’s metrics suggest he deserves a spot.
Similarly, Kevin Dotson of the Los Angeles Rams has been a driving force behind the team’s consistent running game. His performance could warrant a place over Joe Thuney of the Chicago Bears.
Another contender is Isaac Seumalo of the Pittsburgh Steelers, whose impressive blocking metrics have contributed to team success, making him a deserving candidate over Trey Smith of the Kansas City Chiefs.
Finally, Chase Young and Tyler Warren are also candidates for consideration. Young’s speed and pressure rate make him a valuable asset, while Warren’s production as a rookie tight end rivals that of Travis Kelce of the Kansas City Chiefs.
As the Pro Bowl approaches, the debate over these snubs will likely continue. The final selections may shift as players are added as replacements, yet the initial roster has already ignited conversations about recognition and performance in the NFL.
