Netflix has recently launched a new series titled His & Hers, which has generated significant buzz among critics and viewers alike. Released on January 8, 2026, this six-part adaptation of Alison Feeney’s crime novel features Tessa Thompson and Jon Bernthal in leading roles as an investigative journalist and a police detective, respectively. Their shared romantic history adds complexity as they tackle a challenging murder-mystery case.
Critical reactions to His & Hers have been mixed, with some reviewers praising its unique storytelling while others express disappointment. While the series begins as a conventional murder mystery, it reportedly evolves into a deeper exploration of themes such as grief, marriage, and parenthood. This narrative shift has captivated some audiences, but not all critics agree on its effectiveness.
Mixed Reviews Highlight Key Themes
Among the more favorable reviews, Michael Peyton from IGN awarded the series a score of 9 out of 10, emphasizing that it “keeps you hooked from beginning to end.” Similarly, Aramide Tinubu of Variety described it as “deliciously bonkers,” highlighting its unpredictable nature. In her review for The Guardian, Lucy Mangan rated the show 3.5 out of 5, characterizing it as “bingeable” and providing “comfort television” suitable for early January.
Conversely, some critics have pointed out shortcomings in the execution of the storyline. Reuben Baron of Looper noted the series has “shock value but lacked smarts,” while Daniel Fienberg from The Hollywood Reporter remarked that the chemistry between Bernthal and Thompson was minimal. Time Magazine‘s Judy Berman took a more critical stance, stating that the show was “too grim to be fun” and “too silly to take seriously.”
Unpredictable Finale Captivates Viewers
Despite the mixed reviews, one aspect of the show has garnered universal acclaim: its shocking finale. Critics unanimously agree that the last episode contains an unexpected twist that leaves viewers in disbelief.
“I literally sat in shock, screaming ‘WHAT?!!'”
said Tinubu, while Peyton remarked that the ending “achieves the rare feat of making you think long after the credits roll.” This surprising conclusion may be enough to entice viewers to explore the series, regardless of its other criticisms.
As it stands, His & Hers is now available for streaming on Netflix, and its polarizing reception suggests it will remain a topic of conversation among audiences. Whether you find it “deliciously bonkers” or “too grim to be fun,” the series promises an engaging experience, particularly for those interested in thrilling narratives with unexpected turns.
